When you're putting together a reference library for automotive powersports repair, the same core title can show up in very different packages. One listing offers a brand-new third edition of Tim Gilles's *Automotive Service: Inspection, Maintenance, Repair*. The other is a very good copy of the same book. The real question is whether you want a pristine, updated copy or a pre-owned book that has already been used by someone else.
Quick Verdict
If you want an unused copy that feels ready for study, the new third edition is the choice. If you prefer a pre-owned book and you're comfortable with possible highlighting, the very good copy is the better fit.
At a Glance
| Consideration | New Third Edition | Very Good Hardcover |
|---|---|---|
| Price | USD 42.49 | USD 48.21 |
| Condition | Brand New | Very Good |
| Format | Hardcover | Hardcover |
| Notable details | Revised, resource CD | ISBN 9781305110595 |
Where Each Product Wins
The new third edition wins when you want an adult-education-oriented reference and a copy that hasn't been used by someone else. The very good copy wins when you want a used book you can annotate freely or when you need to match a particular printing for a class.
Product Notes
New Third Edition (Brand New)
The new third edition includes revised content and a bundled resource CD, giving you extra material beyond the printed pages. Its listed price is USD 42.49, and the condition is brand new, so there are no previous owner's marks to work around. The educational level targets adult and further education, which fits a student or a home hobbyist building a professional foundation. The main limitation is that the seller states the sale is final; if the book doesn't work for you, you will not get a refund. That means you should be confident about the third edition before you commit. If you want a clean, revised reference with a CD included and a lower listed price, the new third edition is a sensible pick.
Very Good Hardcover (ISBN 9781305110595)
This very good hardcover is listed at USD 48.21, and its strongest appeal is the specific ISBN 9781305110595 shown with the book. If you're matching a syllabus or tracking a particular printing, that identifier removes guesswork. The book is described as well-cared-for with limited use; all pages are legible, though there may be minor wear or slight highlighting. That means you can read and reference it without missing content, but you should expect some signs of previous reading. The trade-off is the cost: you pay more for a used copy than for the brand-new one. If you don't mind marks on the pages and you prefer an identifiable hardcover, this is a practical option for your automotive powersports repair shelf.
Final Choice by Use Case
If you're building a home reference for automotive powersports repair and want a clean copy that stays pristine, choose the New Third Edition. If you're taking a class or you prefer a pre-owned book you can write in, the Very Good Hardcover is your match. Either way, you get Tim Gilles's guide to inspection, maintenance, and repair; the real difference is whether you value a pristine package with extra media or an identified book that has already lived a little.
